Why I Didn't Hire Them (Even If the Interview Went Great)

Ep #275: Why I Didn't Hire Them (Even If the Interview Went Great) Have you ever walked out of an interview thinking, “That went amazing!”...only to never hear back? Or maybe you were this close to landing a role and couldn’t figure out why it didn’t work out? Well, I recently spent several days reviewing 30+ applications and interviewing candidates for a contract role on Team Badass—and what I saw confirmed a lot of what I’ve been coaching you to do all along. Some people absolutely stood out. Others missed the mark entirely. So in this episode, I’m sharing what worked, what didn’t, and how the strongest applicants presented themselves in a way that felt clear, aligned, and easy to say yes to. You’ll hear the real reasons certain people moved forward—and why others didn’t—even when we had amazing conversations. I’ll also share what surprised me, what turned me off instantly, and how the follow-up made a bigger difference than most people realize. This episode of Women Changing Leadership with Stacy Mayer is packed with real examples from my own hiring process so you can feel more confident and strategic the next time you put yourself out there. Unlock the missing piece in your leadership development. Take the quiz: www.ReadytoBePromoted.com Before you go — if you haven't subscribed to this podcast yet, do it now. And head over to stac ymayer.com/youtube and subscribe to my YouTube channel while you're at it. If this episode hit home for you, share it. Post it to your LinkedIn. Send it to a colleague, a friend, anyone who needs to hear it. We are navigating this AI era together, and I don't take lightly the opportunity to be part of that journey with you. And if you're ready to stop navigating it alone — whether you've just been laid off or you're simply done white-knuckling your way through a chaotic landscape — I want to work with you personally. Go to stacymayer.com/discovery and schedule your free call. We'll map out a career strategy built specifically for you. I'll see you there. 👊🏽💚

Listen