PNW Haunts & Homicides
True Crime & Paranormal
About
Join Caitlyn and Cassie as they chat about true crime, the paranormal, and all kinds of spooky sh*t in the Pacific Northwest. Just two "normal-ish" friends who wanted more local, creepy stories so they never sleep or leave their houses again. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/pnw-haunts-homicides--5955451/support .
Episodes
- Lindsey Baum: Unsolved | McCleary, WA
This episode recounts the 2009 disappearance of ten-year-old Lindsey Baum from McCleary, Washington. It covers the initial investigation, persons of interest, and the current status of the unsolved case.
- Portland’s Titanic Exhibit: A Haunting Tragedy
This episode discusses the Titanic Artifact Exhibit at OMSI, exploring the historical tragedy, survivor stories, and modern connections including the Titan submersible. It also touches on paranormal reports and a mysterious flood at the Vo…
- America’s Only Emperor: The Strange, True Story of Emperor Norton
This episode explores the story of Joshua Abraham Norton, a self-declared Emperor in San Francisco. It covers his life, his decrees, and the unique relationship he had with the city and its residents.
- He Never Made It to the Funeral: The Murder of George Cecil David
This episode examines the disappearance and murder of Indigenous artist George Cecil David. His unsolved case became a landmark for Washington's Missing & Murdered Indigenous People (MMIWP) Cold Case Unit.
- Creepy People Chronicles: Shadow Figures & Ghost Sex
This episode of PNW Haunts & Homicides shares listener stories of paranormal encounters. Topics include a shadow figure sighting and ghostly apparitions.
- The Fenn Treasure: A Real-Life Hunt That Turned Deadly
This collaborative episode with Rainy Day Rabbit Holes podcast delves into the story of Forrest Fenn and the decade-long treasure hunt. It covers the 24-line poem, the clues, and the controversies, including lives lost during the search in…
- Tylenol Murders
This episode, originally from the "Rainy Day Rabbit Holes" podcast, discusses the 1982 Tylenol Murders and 1986 Excedrin poisonings. It covers the investigations, the conviction of Stella Nickell for product tampering, and the events' infl…
- Not an Accident: The Cheryl Keeton Murder
This episode examines the 1986 Cheryl Keeton murder case, initially staged as an accident. It covers the evidence, timeline, and the investigation that led to justice almost a decade later.
- Superstitions From Around the World
This episode of PNW Haunts & Homicides explores various superstitions from around the world, including well-known beliefs and bizarre cultural practices. It covers superstitions related to everyday life, sleep, and theatrical lore, highlig…
- The Nesbitt Homestead Murders | Hood River, Oregon
This episode of PNW Haunts & Homicides investigates the 1900s Nesbitt Homestead murders in Hood River, Oregon. It covers the disappearance of Louisa and Alma Nesbitt and the subsequent murder case.
- Ghouls of Grays Harbor
This episode explores Grays Harbor, Washington, focusing on the historical figure Billy Gohl, known as the "Ghoul of Grays Harbor," and delves into local legends of hauntings at the Polson Museum and aboard The Lady Washington ship.
- Mel's Hole of Mysteries
This episode of PNW Haunts & Homicides discusses Mel's Hole, a mysterious location brought to public attention by Mel Waters in a series of radio interviews. The episode compiles content previously released as a three-part series.
- Friday the 13th: Paraskevidekatriaphobia & A History of Bad Luck
This episode examines the history of Friday the 13th, exploring the origins and persistence of superstitions surrounding the date, known as paraskevidekatriaphobia. It traces the date's legacy from historical events to its cultural embeddi…
- What Lies Beneath the Oregon Zoo
This episode delves into the hidden history of the Oregon Zoo, revealing its past as a poor farm and sanatorium, where undocumented burials were discovered. It recounts the tragic deaths of Roger Adams in 1970 and Carl Stanley Ross Sr. in…
- The Columbia Edgewater Country Club Car Bombing
This episode recounts the 1955 car bombing at the Columbia Edgewater Country Club, which resulted in the death of Oliver Kermit Smith. The investigation led to the conviction of Victor Laurence Wolf, while Smith's wife, Marjorie, was acqui…
- Reddit AITA: Paranormal Nonbelievers
Caitlyn and Cassie discuss Reddit AITA stories focusing on individuals who do not believe in the paranormal. They explore how to interact with someone sharing a ghost story from a nonbeliever's perspective.
- The Disappearance of Maurice, Martha, Louis, Jennie, and Betty Sodder
This episode of PNW Haunts & Homicides discusses the 1945 disappearance of the five Sodder children from their Fayetteville, West Virginia home after a Christmas Eve fire. The episode features Alecia of Truly Twisted and explores the endur…
- Viva La Overreaction
This episode features Trevin and Amanda from Live, Laugh, Larceny discussing petty crimes and overreactions. Topics include vacation mishaps, a mysterious underwater sound known as "The Bloop," and a can of bear mace incident.
- The Chateau at The Oregon Caves: Chilling History & Hauntings
This episode explores the history and hauntings of The Chateau at The Oregon Caves National Monument. It covers the discovery of the caves, the history of The Chateau, and accounts of its resident ghost, Elizabeth.
- Derrick Engebretson: The Nightmare Before Christmas
This episode of PNW Haunts & Homicides discusses the 1998 disappearance of Derrick Joe Engebretson from Pelican Butte, Oregon. It covers the timeline, details, and theories surrounding this unsolved mystery in the Pacific Northwest.
- Trees of Christmas Past
This episode explores an abandoned Christmas tree farm in Oregon that was revitalized by Mark Rohlfs and later recovered from the 2020 Oregon wildfires. It also includes Cassie's childhood experiences working on a Christmas tree farm.
- Missing in Wenatchee: The Decker Sisters Case
In May 2025, the three Decker sisters disappeared during a scheduled visit with their father, Travis Caleb Decker. Their bodies were discovered days later, and forensic evidence linked their father to the killings. Travis Decker’s remains…
- Creepy People Chronicles: Cryptids & Wake-Up Calls
This episode of PNW Haunts & Homicides shares listener stories, including an update about mischievous spirits and the Delaney House, a cryptid sighting, and an eerie wake-up call. It also mentions an oracle card reading and a house fire th…
- Labubu Adventures - Unboxing Joy
This bonus episode from PNW Haunts & Homicides explores the world of Labubu collectibles. The hosts, initially skeptical, discuss their experience with the cultural phenomenon.
- Susan Cox Powell: Fire & Fallout | The Aftermath | Pt. 2
This episode covers the aftermath of the Susan Cox Powell case, focusing on the investigation following a tragic event in Graham, Washington. It examines systemic failures, the Cox family's activism, and the impact on supervised-visitation…
- Beyond the Cards: Art, Tarot, and Liminal Spaces
This episode explores the intersection of art, tarot, and spirituality with guest David of Whiskey Terra Foxtrot. The discussion covers his creative process in designing "The Liminal Deck" and the significance of symbolism in tarot.
- Susan Cox Powell: Vanished | West Valley City, UT
Susan Cox Powell vanished from her West Valley City, Utah, home in December 2009. This episode explores the details surrounding her disappearance, including her secret will, journal entries, and home video.
- The Cannibal at the North End of the World: Baxbakwalanuksiwe’
This episode of PNW Haunts & Homicides explores the Kwakwaka'wakw folklore surrounding Baxbakwalanuksiwe', also known as the Man-Eater at the North End of the World. The discussion includes the Hamat'sa, or "Cannibal Dance," and its cultur…
- The Unsolved Murders of the Evangelista Family
This episode discusses the unsolved 1929 murders of the Evangelista family. The crime is known as both the Detroit Occult Murders and the St. Aubin Street Massacre.
- Shrunken Heads & Shipwrecks: More of Marsh’s Free Museum
This episode of PNW Haunts & Homicides explores Marsh's Free Museum, focusing on its shrunken head artifact and the history of the SS Admiral Benson shipwreck. It delves into the museum's unique collection and coastal legends.
- Salem’s Gallows & Grace: The Delaney Murder & Rachel Belden Brooks
This episode of PNW Haunts & Homicides examines the 1865 Delaney murder in Salem, Oregon. It details the investigation, trial, and the story of Rachel Belden Brooks, an enslaved woman who sought justice.
- Creepy People Chronicles: Mediums & Mischievous Spirits
This episode of PNW Haunts & Homicides discusses paranormal and true crime in the Pacific Northwest. It includes listener tales about a mysterious message received by mediums, a mischievous spirit, and a story from the Nightmare Factory in…
- Ghosts of the Delaney House
This episode explores the haunted Delaney House in Salem, Oregon. The current owner shares the house's history, and a paranormal investigator provides insights into the location.
- Normandale Park Shooting: Pt. 2 – Two Tales of One City
This episode discusses the aftermath of the Normandale Park Shooting, focusing on Benjamin Jeffrey Smith's arrest, plea, and sentencing, as well as the death of Deg. It examines the community's reactions, the role of institutions, and the…
- The Normandale Park Shooting: Pt. 1
This episode discusses the Normandale Park shooting that occurred on February 19, 2022, in Portland, Oregon. It covers the timeline of events, the background of Benjamin Jeffrey Smith, and the work of organizers present. The episode explor…
- Near-Death Experiences (NDEs)
This episode discusses near-death experiences (NDEs), including common features reported by people who have them. It explores the potential link between NDEs and the brain's chemical responses, blending personal anecdotes with scientific i…
- The Raines Transcript
This episode, "The Raines Transcript," delves into the story of the Raines family and the elaborate deception that led to the downfall of their Pacific Northwest timber empire. It is a previously exclusive bonus episode that the hosts freq…
- Haunted Dolls and the Labubu Curse
This episode of PNW Haunts & Homicides, with guest co-host Chris, explores haunted dolls and the Labubu phenomenon. The discussion covers unsettling Reddit tales of events caused by haunted dolls and the backstory of Labubu, from its origi…
- "The Sinners All Bow" with Kate Winkler Dawson
This episode from Ye Olde Crime features author and podcaster Kate Winkler Dawson. She discusses her book “The Sinners All Bow,” which explores a nineteenth-century mystery using modern investigative techniques.
- Madame Mustache: The Wild West’s Most Badass Gambler
This episode from PNW Haunts & Homicides features a story from the Rainy Day Rabbit Holes podcast. It focuses on Eleanor Dumont, known as Madame Mustache, a gambler and businesswoman in the Wild West.
- Creepy People Chronicles: Spirit Guides, Dreams, and Haunted Encounters
This episode explores listener stories including a mysterious face on a baby monitor and a whimsical dream encounter. It also features supernatural encounters shared by Aurora and Fanni from Bad Witches Productions.
- The Disappearance of Melanie Ethier
This episode of PNW Haunts & Homicides discusses the 1996 disappearance of Melanie Ethier, who vanished while walking home in New Liskeard, Ontario. The hosts explore theories surrounding her disappearance.
- Vanished: The Jami Sue Hagel Sherer Case (Part 2)
This episode focuses on the investigation, trial, and conviction of Steve Sherer for the murder of Jami Sue Hagel Sherer. It covers the evidence gathered and the testimony that led to his conviction, as well as his continued actions from p…
- Vanished: The Jami Sue Hagel Sherer Case (Part 1)
This episode, part one of a two-part series, examines the 1990 disappearance of Jami Sue Hagel Sherer from Redmond, Washington. It covers her life, career, and the escalating issues within her marriage before she vanished.
- The Pimlico Mystery: Chloroform, Secrets, and a Victorian Acquittal
This episode, presented by Ye Olde Crime, investigates the death of Thomas Edwin Bartlett. The discussion covers related topics such as quality dentistry, background checks for doctors, and the procurement of poison.
- Magdalena Zuk: Marsa Alam, Egypt
This episode of PNW Haunts and Homicides covers the case of Magdalena Zuk, who died after falling from a hospital window in Egypt. Her death was ruled a suicide, but it sparked widespread speculation in Poland.
- Skye Budnick: Hokkaido, Japan
This episode, a guest contribution from The Last Trip, covers the 2008 disappearance of 21-year-old college student Skye Budnick in Hokkaido, Japan. Budnick was last seen in Noboribetsu before heading to Sapporo, and a draft suicide note w…
- Neil Stonechild: Deadly Saskatoon Starlight Tours
This episode discusses the death of Neil Stonechild, a 17-year-old Saulteaux First Nations teen, whose body was found in a snow-covered field. The episode also examines the practice known as the Starlight Tours, where Indigenous people wer…
- The Field of Vampires: Unearthing Historical Fears
This episode, from Ye Olde Crime, explores the vampire fields of Poland and Eastern European superstitions. It also discusses the importance of 3D printing and facial reconstruction.
- Heroines of Horror: The True Haunting Behind Vessel
Aurora and Fanni from Bad Witches Productions discuss the true hauntings and creative process behind their horror short, Vessel. They explore the connection between women's experiences with the paranormal and broader struggles to be believ…