Paired Nightmares

About

Two voices, one story. Every week, a husband-and-wife duo dive into a chilling true crime case or eerie mystery that haunts long after the lights go out. From unsolved murders to spine-tingling tales, Paired Nightmares brings you detailed storytelling, dark insights, and just enough shivers to keep you coming back for more.

Episodes

• The Murder of Anna Moriah Wilson 2026-05-06

  This episode recounts the 2022 murder of professional cyclist Anna Moriah Wilson in Austin, Texas. The case involved a jealousy-driven killing, a romantic triangle, and an international manhunt that led to a conviction.

• The Beast of Bray Road 2026-04-29

  This episode of Paired Nightmares discusses The Beast of Bray Road, a wolf-like creature reported in Wisconsin. The creature is described as bipedal with glowing eyes, and various theories about its identity are explored.

• The Disappearance of Daniel Robinson 2026-04-22

  Daniel Robinson, a young geologist, went missing in June 2021 near Buckeye, Arizona. His case gained national attention due to unusual circumstances, including his vehicle being found crashed in a remote desert area. Despite extensive sear…

• The Bell Witch 2026-04-15

  The Bell Witch is an American folk legend about the Bell family being haunted by a mysterious entity in early 19th-century Tennessee. The spirit, known as the "Bell Witch," allegedly targeted John and Betsy Bell and could speak, shape-shif…

• The Co-ed Killer 2026-04-08

  This episode discusses Ed Kemper, an American serial killer known as the "Co-ed Killer." He was active in California in the early 1970s and murdered 10 people, including his grandparents, several young women, and his mother before turning…

• St. Augustine Lighthouse 2026-04-01

  This episode explores the St. Augustine Lighthouse, a historic 165-foot tall lighthouse built in 1874 on the northeastern coast of Florida. The site also functions as a maritime museum, showcasing exhibits on local shipwrecks, coastal hist…

• The Kansas City Butcher 2026-03-25

  This episode covers the case of Robert Berdella, known as the "Kansas City Butcher," a serial killer who operated in the 1980s, kidnapping, torturing, and murdering at least six young men. He dismembered his victims' bodies, was arrested i…

• The Aswang 2026-03-18

  The Aswang is a shape-shifting monster in Philippine folklore, combining traits of vampires, ghouls, and witches. This episode of Paired Nightmares discusses the creature and its characteristics.

• Jeanette DePalma 2026-03-13

  This episode discusses the unsolved death of Jeanette DePalma, a sixteen-year-old girl who disappeared in August 1972. The case is known for alleged occult elements and is frequently discussed in true crime and paranormal circles due to th…