Murder, Mystery & Makeup
True Crime & Paranormal
Episodes
- Inside the Mansion: Menendez Brothers & the SHOCKING Evidence Revisited
The Menendez brothers case is revisited, detailing the 1989 murders of their wealthy parents, José and Kitty Menendez, in Beverly Hills. The episode explores the investigation, the brothers' trial, allegations of abuse, and post-trial upda…
- From Obsession To Murder: The Girlfriend Who Couldn't Let Go - Shayna Hubers
This episode covers the case of Shayna Hubers, who was convicted of murdering her boyfriend, Ryan Poston. The narrative details her obsessive behavior, the events leading to the murder, and the subsequent trial, including interrogation tap…
- What drove this “perfect wife” to kill her husband? The unbelievable case of Clara Harris
This episode covers the case of Clara Harris, a Houston dentist accused of murdering her husband. The description details the events leading up to the crime, including David Harris's affair and Clara's confrontation with him and his mistre…
- The serial killer you’ve never heard of… Killed her BF, husband, and 7 more? Who is Kelly Cochran
This episode explores the disturbing true crime case of Kelly and Jason Cochran from Iron River, Michigan. After the murder of Air Force veteran Chris Regan, the investigation uncovered a couple involved in a deadly pact, a cheating scanda…
- Murder By Mushrooms?? Or A Big Mistake? The twisted case of Erin Patterson
Bailey Sarian covers the Erin Patterson case, a true crime story originating in Leongatha, Australia. A lunch gathering led to three fatalities, raising questions about whether deadly mushrooms or intentional murder were the cause. The epi…
- Do These Fan Theories Solve the Case? True Crime Q&A
In this Q&A episode, host Bailey Sarian addresses listener questions and reacts to fan theories regarding well-known true crime cases and unsolved mysteries. The discussion covers conspiracy theories and clues suggested by listeners.
- Remember Terri Schiavo?? What was that about? How a Private Battle became a Public WAR
The episode discusses the Terri Schiavo case, where her husband and parents fought over her life support after she fell into a persistent vegetative state. The conflict escalated, drawing in politicians and religious figures, and became a…
- The Shocking Case of Robert Pickton | 49 Women, A Pig Farm, and A Horrifying Secret
This episode delves into the horrifying case of Robert Pickton, known as the Pig Farmer Killer, who preyed on vulnerable women on his Vancouver farm. It examines alleged police corruption, cover-ups, and unanswered questions surrounding th…
- The Chilling Code That Was Never Cracked... Or Was It? - The Zodiac Killer
This episode covers the case of the Zodiac Killer, a serial murderer active for over 50 years. The episode discusses the killer's victims, methods, taunting communications, and the ongoing mystery surrounding his identity despite decades o…
- The Lipstick Killer: Murderer, Scapegoat, or Something Much Darker?
This episode discusses the 1945 Chicago Lipstick Killer case. Detectives found a message written in the victim's lipstick, leading to a city-wide panic and a manhunt. The episode questions whether the captured suspect was truly the killer.
- 3+ Hours of Horrifying Cannibal Stories (You've Been WARNED)
This episode of Murder, Mystery & Makeup presents a compilation of over 3 hours of stories focusing on the top 6 most horrifying cannibals in history. The episode is themed around cannibals, with stories chosen to potentially be listened t…
- The Grandma Who Poisoned Her Family (and Laughed About It) Nannie Doss *Podcast Exclusive*
This episode covers the story of Nannie Doss, also known as the "Giggling Granny," who poisoned multiple family members, including husbands and children. The narrative explores her difficult childhood, romantic relationships, and her distu…
- He Was a Respected Doctor… Until They Found the Bodies - Harold Shipman
This episode of Murder, Mystery & Makeup discusses the case of Harold Shipman, a doctor known as "Dr. Death." Shipman is suspected of killing hundreds of patients under the guise of medical care, deceiving them and manipulating records for…
- The BDSM Texts That Exposed a Killer: The Elaine O’Hara Case (Podcast Exclusive)
This episode details the Elaine O’Hara case, starting with the discovery of tools in a reservoir. Investigators used cell phone data to uncover a plot detailed in thousands of text messages, leading to the arrest of Graham Dwyer for murder.
- She Used Flypaper to Kill Her Husbands (And It Actually Worked)
This episode covers the true crime story of Lyda Trueblood, known as "Idaho's Lady Bluebeard," who was accused of murdering her husbands. The narrative includes details about suspicious deaths, a prison escape, and her notoriety as a poten…
- Trapped & Left to Die...in a suitcase?! WTF was Sarah Boone Thinking?
The Murder, Mystery & Makeup podcast discusses the disturbing case of Sarah Boone, who allegedly trapped and left her partner Jorge Torres Jr. to die in a suitcase. Boone initially claimed it was an accident, but police discovered videos s…
- Disturbed, Unhinged and Deadly - The Psychotic Rage of Amy Bishop
This episode covers the case of Amy Bishop, a Harvard neuroscientist who committed a conference room massacre in 2010. The episode details her chilling past, including a dead brother, missing police records, and unsolved bomb plots, sugges…
- JAIL CELL JUSTICE?! Evil Guard Gets More Than He Bargained For | Joan Little
The Murder, Mystery & Makeup podcast covers the story of Joan Little, a young Black woman who made headlines in the 1970s. Facing an attacker in her jail cell, she fought for her life, resulting in a trial that captivated America and impac…
- Serial Killers, Cults, & Cannibals: The *TWISTED* Case of Ottis Toole
The episode details the horrifying case of Ottis Toole and his accomplice Henry Lee Lucas, exploring their involvement in cannibalism and a cult. The narrative also touches upon connections to Ted Bundy and the inspiration for the show "Am…
- The World’s WORST KIllers: 4+ Bingeworthy Hours of True Crime
This Murder, Mystery & Makeup compilation features over 3 hours of content on notorious serial killers, exploring their crimes and motives. The episode is designed to be suitable for background listening.
- NFL superstar to cold blooded KILLER - the downfall of Aaron Hernandez
This episode discusses the life and crimes of Aaron Hernandez, detailing his journey from an NFL player to a convicted murderer.
- Women Who Kill: 3+ Hours of True Crime
This podcast episode is a compilation of true crime stories focused on women who kill, presented in the Murder, Mystery & Makeup series. The episode is over 3 hours long and is intended to be listened to in the background.
- A Victorian lesbian romance ends in madness, jealousy, and MURDER?? - Alice Mitchell & Freda Ward
The podcast discusses the late 1800s Memphis, Tennessee story of Alice Mitchell and Freda Ward. This same-sex, Gilded Age romance reportedly involved passion, jealousy, secrets, and stalking, ending in madness and murder.
- Billionaire Island: The Secret Predator Network That Escaped Justice
This episode of Murder, Mystery & Makeup discusses Billionaire Island and Brother Paul, exposing a predator network that evaded justice. It delves into the dark aspects of power and privilege.
- Fan Favorite & **UPDATE** Love, Lies, & Lust: What Really Happened With Jodi Arias?
Bailey Sarian provides an update on the Jodi Arias case, a topic frequently requested by viewers. She also briefly comments on her makeup for the episode and shares various social media and shopping links.
- He Kept His Daughter in the Basement for 24 YEARS
This episode covers the case of Josef Fritzl, a man who held his daughter captive in a basement for 24 years, subjecting her to abuse. The description also includes promotional links and social media details for the podcast host.
- A psychotic Alaskan love triangle turned deadly? The twisted case of Mechele Linehan
This episode covers the unusual and complex case of Mechele Linehan, a former exotic dancer. The story involves elements of charm, manipulation, and calculation, leading to a murder.
- The Crossbow Cannibal - PhD Student and *Secret* Serial Killer?!
The episode covers the case of Stephen Griffiths, known as the Crossbow Cannibal, detailing his bizarre characteristics and shocking actions in England during 2009 and 2010.
- “No one could hear them scream.” The babysitter from hell - Christine Falling
This episode discusses Christine Falling, referred to as "the babysitter from hell," who committed neglect and manipulation. Between 1980 and 1982, she was responsible for the deaths of five infants and one elderly man, prompting questions…
- INTERNET MURDERS - An MMM Compilation Episode
This compilation episode of Murder, Mystery & Makeup focuses on internet-related murders and crimes. The episode is over 3 hours long and was created for viewers who enjoy listening to content while falling asleep.
- Failed Country Music Star Turned Fast Food Killer? - what was going on with Paul Dennis Reid??
The episode discusses Paul Dennis Reid, also known as the 'Fast Food Killer,' who transitioned from a failed country music career to committing robberies and murders in Tennessee in the late 1990s. His case highlights themes of shattered d…
- "People die, they should just get over it." - The Monster Who Haunted Australia: Ivan Milat
This episode of Murder, Mystery & Makeup covers the crimes of Ivan Milat, the Australian serial killer known as the "Backpack Killer." It details his attacks on young travelers, the discovery of victims in a state forest, and the investiga…
- Tragic accident or betrayed by her "friends"?? The unknown answers with Tamla Horsford's case
The episode discusses the death of Tamla Horsford, who fell from a balcony during a girls' weekend. The host questions whether her death was a tragic accident or a racially motivated murder, noting that Horsford was the only Black woman in…
- Fan Favorite & **UPDATE** The Charles Manson Cult Killings
Bailey Sarian covers the Charles Manson Cult Killings, sharing her research challenges and acknowledging listener suggestions. She also provides links to her social media and reading recommendations.
- A "freak accident" or pure evil?? Unraveling the death of Phoebe Handsjuk
This episode of Murder, Mystery & Makeup investigates the baffling death of 24-year-old Phoebe Handsjuk, who was found deceased after a 12-story fall into her apartment building's garbage chute. Investigators and experts remain puzzled by…
- Grandma is secretly a serial killer and CANNIBAL?? The shocking crimes of the Granny Ripper
This episode discusses the shocking crimes of Tamara Samsonova, the Russian serial killer and cannibal known as the Granny Ripper. Despite her grandmotherly appearance, Samsonova murdered and consumed human flesh, meticulously documenting…
- World Famous Olympian turned murderer?? Did He Do it or Honest Mistake?
This episode of Murder, Mystery & Makeup covers the case of Oscar Pistorius, a world-famous Olympian who overcame childhood amputations to achieve athletic success. The podcast explores the events of Valentine's Day 2013, when his girlfrie…
- She kept her secret lover in the attic for 10 YEARS and no one knew?!
The Murder, Mystery & Makeup podcast discusses the story of Dolly, who kept a secret lover hidden in her attic for 10 years. What began as a desire for romance took a sinister turn, impacting multiple men.
- When a superfan goes too far for his "art" - The Wannabe Dexter Killer
In this episode of Murder, Mystery & Makeup, Bailey Sarian covers the case of Mark Twitchell. Twitchell, described as a "Dexter" fanboy, narcissist, and pathological liar, made a poor attempt at becoming a serial killer and received a life…
- Caregiver to Killer: Amelia Dyer & The Dark World of Baby Farming
This episode discusses Amelia Dyer, who operated a "baby farm" in the late 1800s. Instead of caring for infants, Dyer committed unthinkable acts against them.
- Bind, Torture, Kill: Who was the BTK Killer?
Bailey Sarian discusses the crimes of Dennis Rader, known as the BTK killer, in this episode of Murder, Mystery & Makeup.
- Don't look behind the mirror!! The unknown Candyman case and famous horror story
This episode of Murder, Mystery & Makeup delves into the true story behind the Candyman urban legend, focusing on the 1980s Chicago murder of Ruthie Mae McCoy, who was killed by an intruder entering through her bathroom mirror. The host al…
- Post Office Massacre: Patrick Sherrill and the "Going Postal" Tragedy (Podcast Exclusive)
This episode discusses the 1986 "going postal" tragedy, detailing the mass shooting committed by USPS worker Patrick Sherrill in Oklahoma, which became the deadliest lone-man shooting in the state's history.
- How Snapchat caught this parent killer red-handed
This episode details the case of Chandler Halderson, who escalated from lying to murder. His downfall came when his girlfriend caught him through a Snapchat screenshot.
- Fan Favorite: One of the Most Hated Women In America - Casey Anthony
This episode revisits the popular case of Casey Anthony, dubbed one of "the most hated women in America." Host Bailey Sarian includes recent updates on Anthony's personal life alongside the original story.
- The Kansas City Vampire - Convinced he had to eat human flesh to live?! (Podcast Exclusive)
This episode covers the disturbing case of Marc Vincent Sappington, the so-called Kansas City Vampire. The podcast explores his life, motivations possibly linked to drug use and paranoia, and the terrifying crimes, including cannibalism, t…
- He wanted too cook and eat his wife and friends?! The Cannibal Cop
This episode covers the case of Gilberto Valle, a police officer who harbored extreme fantasies of kidnapping, killing, raping, and eating women. Despite not having acted on these desires, his online obsessions led to his arrest and legal…
- The Killer Granny NO ONE Suspected: Dorothea Puente
This episode covers the story of Dorothea Puente, who used her elderly appearance as a disguise to carry out serial murders and steal her victims' social security benefits. The host emphasizes that one cannot judge a book by its cover.
- The Chilling Confessions of Serial Killer Mack Ray Edwards (Podcast Exclusive)
This episode covers the chilling confessions of Mack Ray Edwards, a serial killer believed to have murdered six children in Los Angeles County between 1953 and 1970. The host, Bailey Sarian, discusses the gruesome details of the case.
- cold-blooded killer or FRAMED? Was Alice Crimmins really guilty?
This episode of Murder, Mystery & Makeup revisits the case of Alice Crimmins, who was convicted of killing her children. The host questions whether Crimmins was truly guilty or if she was framed, suggesting potential bias from investigator…