Mothboys
True Crime & Paranormal
About
A podcast on Cryptids, Conspiracies, and the Unknown.
Episodes
- The Freeport Owlman & Flipper
On this episode of Mothboys, The boys discuss The Freeport Owlman, a winged cryptid with a love for 2010s pop music and Flipper, a truly heinous creature. We also chat the latest updates in the Arkansas dragon wars. Mothboys is sponsored b…
- The Pope Lick Monster (Mothboys 7th Anniversary Special)
On this episode of Mothboys, The boys celebrate the big seven, by discussing breaking Cryptid news before settling in and talking about The Pope Lick Monster, a terrifying half goat/half human who hangs on an unnecessarily high railroad tr…
- The Alien Birds Of Montana
On this episode of Mothboys, The boys discuss a trucker couple(with a questionable age gap) who ran into a UFO carrying mini alien birds on the Montana highway. We also chat about Mothman and ghost light sighting that have happened in a si…
- The Disappearance of Sandra Hughes & The Brazilian Lead Masks Case.
On the season 6 premiere of Mothboys, The boys reunite after a long and very undeserved hiatus and discuss Sandra Hughes who vanished mysteriously in the woods and the strange tale of two dead bodies found with lead masks. WE PROMISE WE AR…
- Spooky Tales From Traditions: The Ghost Of Ruth Ann Musick And Other Local West Virginia Lore (Halloween Spooktacular 2025)
On this episode of Mothboys, the boys conclude the 2025 Halloween Spooktacular by retelling creepy TRUE stories from the zine Mothboy Mike compiled with the Folklife Center. THIS EPISODE HAS IT ALL....smoking ghosts, alcoholic roosters, pe…
- The Bosak Humanoid (Halloween Spooktacular 2025)
On this episode of Mothboys, the boys continue the 2025 Halloween Spooktacular by discussing The Bosak Humanoid, an unfortunate, yet scary cow-humanoid entity. Somehow they do not make a Bosak/Borat reference, but still this episode is VER…
- The Seaford Poltergeist (Halloween Spooktacular 2025)
On this episode of Mothboys, the boys finally decided that the last week of October was the perfect time to start the 2025 Halloween Spooktacular. On the first of THREE new episodes this week, they discuss The Seaford Poltergeist, an angry…
- The Cole Hollow Road Monster & The Lockridge Monster
On this episode of Mothboys, the boys come back from a long hiatus and discuss The Cole Hollow Road Monster and The Lockridge Monster, two terrifying creatures with possible big feet. We also discuss swing daddies, the alpha lifestyle, and…
- The 1966 Akron UFO Chase
On this episode of Mothboys, Jake takes the boys to film school while discussing the real life 1966 multi-state UFO chase that inspired the hit film Close Encounters of the Third Kind. We also discuss junk food, how sports movies are coole…
- John Titor
On this episode of Mothboys, Matt talks time travel, and possibly the most famous time travel of all time...JOHN TITOR. We also talk curses, terminator, and being a creep on internet forums. Mothboys is sponsored by: Visit Braxton, WV -Bra…
- The Enfield Poltergeist
On this episode of Mothboys, the boys delve into the infamous Enfield Poltergeist case, exploring the chaotic events that unfolded in the Hodgson household. They discuss the strange occurrences, including flying objects and violent trances…
- Devil Monkeys and the Deridder Roadkill
On this episode of Mothboys, Mothboy Mike introduces Matt and Jake to Devil Monkeys and the Deridder Roadkill, which is quite possibly some of the most compelling evidence of a cryptid ever recorded!!!! We also talk road trips, the alpha l…
- Barney and Betty Hill UFO Incident
On this episode of Mothboys, The boys celebrate six years of being a podcast by discussing the Barney and Betty Hill incident, quite possibly one of the most popular alien abduction tales of all time. We also make excessive amounts of call…
- North Shore Monster
On this episode of Mothboys, The boys embrace Mormon culture and discuss dirty soda, Bigfoot, and the NORTH SHORE MONSTER, a large crocodile, horse, bat like creature that calls the Great Salt Lake home. This episode is so good, that criti…
- The Pangboche Hand
On the season 5 premiere of Mothboys, The boys catch up after a long hiatus and present the insane tale of The Pangboche Hand. This story has everything from Yeti's to famous actors, and is truly one you CAN NOT miss. Mothboys is sponsored…
- The Crazy Critter Of Bald Mountain & The Bremerton Monstrosity
On this episode of Mothboys, The boys celebrate Christmas, when they chat about the creepy Bremerton Monstrosity and the insanity that is the Crazy Critter Of Bald Mountain. Also lots of solid info about Hallmark Christmas Movie Hunks, Ins…
- The Ghost And The X-Rated Movie Experiment (Halloween Spooktacular 2024)
On this episode of Mothboys, the boys conclude the 2024 Halloween Spooktacular by discussing the mad scientist who came up with the wild ghost and the X-rated movie experiment. Also we give Mothboy Mike the brother and friend of the year a…
- The Cheltenham Ghost (Halloween Spooktacular 2024)
On this episode of Mothboys, the boys proceed with the 2024 Halloween Spooktacular by discussing The Cheltenham Ghost, a truly frightening woman in black said to haunt a house in western England. We also attempt to get a cease and desist f…
- Ectoplasm (Halloween Spooktacular 2024)
On this episode of Mothboys, the boys continue the 2024 Halloween Spooktacular by discussing ectoplasm or "spiritual energy" and Eva Carrière, who was the GOAT of ectoplasm. We also talk about the down right terrifying 2000s MTV dating sho…
- Telly Savalas' Ghost Encounter(Halloween Spooktacular 2024)
On this episode of Mothboys, the boys kick off the 2024 Halloween Spooktacular by discussing famed TV and movie star Telly Savalas and his encounter with a ghost driver. We also discuss the greatest baseball player to ever play the game, a…
- Cryptid Thunderdome Pt. 2(Deciding The Greatest Cryptid Of All Time)
On this episode of Mothboys, The boys finish the first ever "Verne Troyer Cryptid Thunderdome Memorial Tournament", a 26 cryptid bracket style tournament that will decide once and for all.....THE GREATEST CRYPTID OF ALL TIME. On this episo…
- Cryptid Thunderdome Pt. 1(Deciding The Greatest Cryptid Of All Time)
On this episode of Mothboys, The boys kick off the first ever "Verne Troyer Cryptid Thunderdome Memorial Tournament", a 26 cryptid bracket style tournament that will decide once and for all.....THE GREATEST CRYPTID OF ALL TIME. On this epi…
- Predictive Programming
On this episode of Mothboys, The boys discuss how the government has been preparing us for future events via movies and TV when they count down the 10 craziest cases of predictive programming. Also more Fauci talk again..... Mothboys is sp…
- Frank Shaw's Gargoyle
On this episode of Mothboys, we discuss Frank Shaw's Gargoyle, a weird winged creature spotted in the parking lot owned by the always deceitful NASA. Also tons of Fauci talk..... Mothboys is sponsored by: Visit Braxton, WV -Braxton County,…
- Zanfretta UFO Incident
On this episode of Mothboys, Mothboy Mike drops another strange UFO tale when he discusses the Zanfretta UFO Incident, an odd tale of a man who was abducted by aliens anywhere from 5 to 35 times. Mothboys is sponsored by: Visit Braxton, WV…
- The Funeral Mountain Terrashot, The Dungavenhooter, Gary Sudbrink Mystery Calls, And The Avril Lavigne Replacement Theory
On this episode of Mothboys, the boys close out fan appreciation month by choosing THREE fan selected topics. First, Mike shares the tales of The Funeral Mountain Terrashot and The Dungavenhooter two odd CRYPTIDS. Jake educates his fellow…
- The Bluefield Frogoyle & The Wuhnan Toads
On this episode of Mothboys, the boys discuss the difference between frogs and toads, when they discuss the Bluefield Frogoyle and the Wuhnan Toads, two truly peculiar stories about encounters with large amphibian creatures. Mothboys is sp…
- The Black Creek Bigfoot
On this episode of Mothboys, the boys kickstart fan appreciation month by discussing one of the scariest topics yet...Rabies. We also coverTHE BLACK CREEK BIGFOOT, a WNY creature with white fur and insane sprinting skills. Mothboys is spon…
- The Potosi Sheep Slayer
On this episode of Mothboys, the boys pick up the pieces from an eventful and challenging 5th anniversary special by discussing the shocking tale of the Potosi Sheep Slayer. Mothboys is sponsored by: Visit Braxton, WV -Braxton County, West…
- Mothboys Five Year Anniversary Celebration & Announcement!
On this episode of Mothboys, the boys conclu D e the celeb R ation of five ye A rs of the podcast by invitin G a few huge special guests wh O will help cha N ge the future of Mothboy S in 2 024! Mothboys is sponsored by: Visit Braxton, WV…
- The Sky Spitter & The Copenhagen Devil
On this episode of Mothboys, the boys continue to celebrate five years of the podcast by talking about The Sky Spitter & The Copenhagen Devil, two very strange New York encounters that leave the boys shook. The boys also discuss cinema, Ve…
- The Domsten Blobs
On this episode of Mothboys, the boys celebrate five years of the podcast by talking about the Domsten Blobs, a strange blue alien that may have inspired Eiffel 65. Mothboys is sponsored by: Visit Braxton, WV -Braxton County, West Virginia…
- The Octo-Man & The Green Clawed Beast
On this episode of Mothboys, the boys come take a dip in the Ohio river when they discuss both The Octo-Man and the equally terrifying Green Clawed Beast. Mothboys is sponsored by: Visit Braxton, WV -Braxton County, West Virginia is Home o…
- Joe Simonton & The Alien Pancake Encounter
On this episode of Mothboys, the boys dish on America's 2nd favorite breakfast food Pancakes, when they discuss the tale of Joe Simonton and the pancake cooking aliens he encountered in his backyard. Follow along on our moth-journey on Ins…
- Proctor Valley Monster, Waldoboro Little Wild Man, & The Ghost Chicken Of Highgate
On the season 4 premiere of Mothboys, the boys triple the fun when they present creepy tales of blood-thirsty Minotaurs, hairy little men, and a ghost chicken. Follow along on our moth-journey on Instagram at @mothboyspodcast and on Facebo…
- Mari Lwyd
On this episode of Mothboys, the boys celebrate the holiday season with a TON OF A-LIST CELEBRITIES while also discussing the utterly bizarre tradition of Mari Lwyd! Follow along on our moth-journey on Instagram at @mothboyspodcast and on…
- Kitami Abductors & The Uno Head Replacement Alien
On this episode of Mothboys, the boys dive into both the Kitami Abductors & The Uno Head Replacement Alien, which are two of the craziest UFO stories we have come across. Follow along on our moth-journey on Instagram at @mothboyspodcast an…
- Nuckelavee
On this episode of Mothboys, Matt has returned from his alien abduction to present the story of the Nuckelavee, a terrifying creature from Scottish folklore. Follow along on our moth-journey on Instagram at @mothboyspodcast and on Facebook…
- Coffin Hollow And Other Ghost Tales
On this episode of Mothboys, the boys conclude the 2023 HALLOWEEN SPOOKTACULAR by telling the most frightening stories from the book Coffin Hollow And Other Ghost Tales. We also talk about our favorite halloween traditions, such as red sau…
- The Mothman Prophecies(Interview W/ Director Mark Pellington)
On this episode of Mothboys, the boys continue the spooktacular live from the EERIE HORROR FEST, where they dive deep into The Mothman Prophecies(movie and NEW TV SHOW) with legendary director Mark Pellington. We also suggest another batch…
- The Disappearance of Frederick Valentich
On this episode of Mothboys, the boys kick off the 2023 HALLOWEEN SPOOKTACULAR, by discussing the mysterious and possible UFO caused Disappearance of Frederick Valentich. We also suggest some spooky horror double features movie suggestions…
- The Sierra Sounds
On this episode of Mothboys, the boy introduce a new series "Mothboys Mulligans" with a re-do of The Sierra Sounds, a series of truly insane audio documents that capture Bigfoot vocalizations. The "Mothboys Mulligan" series is where we re-…
- Nandi Bear
On this episode of Mothboys, the boy discuss the Verne Troyer sized, bear-hyena hybrid Nandi Bear. We also pay our respects to one of our most respected actors, Verne Troyer, in a very touching musical tribute. Mothboys is sponsored by: Vi…
- Varginha UFO incident
On this episode of Mothboys, the boy discuss the Varginha UFO incident, and the ammonia smelling, people killing creatures that haunted a Brazil town in 1996. Mothboys is sponsored by: Visit Braxton, WV -Braxton County, West Virginia is Ho…
- The Northfield Pigman
On this episode of Mothboys, the 3 little moth-pigs travel back to Vermont where they discuss THE NORTHFIELD PIGMAN. Matt and Mike also discuss an insane UFO experience they had in the same Sherman swamp that John Goodwill saw the White Mo…
- Slide-Rock Bolter & The Hidebehind
On this episode of Mothboys, the boys put on their flannel and discuss the Slide-Rock Bolter and the Hidebehind, two terrifying lumberjack legends. We also beat the dead horse about our distrust of carnies. Mothboys is sponsored by: Visit…
- Mantis Man Of NJ
On this episode of Mothboys, the boys fist pump their way back to NJ when they cover the terrifying MANTIS MAN OF NJ. For the first time ever at the conclusion of the episode, we have a sound effects battle between Mothboy Matt and Mothboy…
- Missing Time
On this episode of Mothboys, the boys discuss a bone chilling collection of accounts that involve missing time. We cover everything from cryptids, humanoids, UFOs, and even those annoying people who like to talk to you on public transporta…
- Return To The Union Screaming House: The Real Story
On this episode of Mothboys, the boys present the true story of The Union Screaming House, with a MOTHBOYS EXCLUSIVE account of the events sent directly to us from one of the members of the family. Mothboys is sponsored by: Visit Braxton,…
- The Ririe Carjackers & The Farmersville Green Man
On this episode of Mothboys, the boys brains melt when they discuss both the Ririe Carjackers and the Farmersville Green Man, two of the most insane topics EVER covered on this show. We also dabble in conspiracies, when we break down the s…