I Think Not!
True Crime & Paranormal
About
From murder, to crooked cops to tax evasion and scams, the world of true crime TV is full of stuff that makes us scream “I Think Not!” If you liked the smash hit comedy podcast "Obsessed with Disappeared," you’ll love this new show from co-hosts and best friends Ellyn Marsh & Joey Taranto. Join Ellyn, Joey – and all the characters that live inside their gorgeous heads – for true stories and the campy television that covers them. Get ready to laugh, cry and think about true crime in a whole new way.
Episodes
- True Crime Rundown: Alex Murdaugh & Kouri Richins
This week while Ellyn is on a short vacation, Joey is joined by podcaster and friend of the show, Rebecca Lavoie (Crime Writers On, These Are Their Stories, and Something’s Off on YouTube). They discuss Alex Murdaugh’s conviction being ove…
- Season 2, Episode 5 (Unsolved Mysteries)
This episode of "I Think Not!" covers three unsolved mysteries: mysterious lights reported in a Texas town, a search for a female robber in Georgia, and the murders of two teenagers in Washington.
- True Crime Rundown: Lee Gilley & Cruise Ships
The True Crime Rundown episode covers the case of Lee Gilley, accused of killing his pregnant wife, and the arrest of 27 people from cruise ships involved in child sexual exploitation.
- Season 2, Episode 4 (Unsolved Mysteries)
This episode of I Think Not! discusses several true crime and human interest stories: a Nebraska police chief is sought for questioning regarding a murder, an Arizona couple defrauded individuals by impersonating doctors, and an Oklahoma f…
- True Crime Rundown: Celeste Rivas Hernandez & D4vd
This episode discusses the murder of 13-year-old Celeste Rivas Hernandez and analyzes the actions of an individual referred to as D4vd. The description also includes a promotional message for IQBAR.
- Season 2, Episode 3 (Unsolved Mysteries)
Season 2, Episode 3 of I Think Not! discusses four unsolved cases: a woman run over by her car, an arsonist in Missouri, a coin scam in New York City, and a mysterious illness affecting an Oakland family.
- True Crime Rundown: D4vd & Ashlee Jenae
On this episode of True Crime Rundown, hosts Ellyn and Joey cover the alleged murder of Celeste Rivas Hernandez by D4vd and the mysterious death of influencer Ashlee Jenae.
- Season 2, Episode 2 (Unsolved Mysteries)
This episode of I Think Not! covers three unsolved mysteries: the murder of a Michigan real estate agent, a statue of Christ reportedly seen blinking, and a Washington policeman's renewed investigation into a 54-year-old murder.
- True Crime Rundown: Celeste Hernandez, D4vd's Arrest & Anna Kepner
Joey and Ellyn discuss recent developments in true crime cases, including movement on the Celeste Hernandez case following D4vd's arrest, an upcoming arraignment for Anna Kepner's step-brother, and a brief update on Taylor Frankie Paul and…
- Episode 24 (Unsolved Mysteries)
This episode of I Think Not! discusses three unsolved mysteries: a teen girl's disappearance and reappearance, a treasure allegedly found in New Mexico caverns, and a torched car associated with a missing person.
- True Crime Rundown: Sandra Birchmore, LISK, Taylor Frankie Paul & More
Ellyn and Joey discuss recent true crime headlines including the Dr. Gerhardt Konig verdict, Lindsay Clancy's legal strategy, updates on Taylor Frankie Paul and Dakota, the Long Island Serial Killer's identity, and new evidence in the Sand…
- Episode 23 (Unsolved Mysteries)
This episode covers an unsolved mystery about a mother searching for her missing son or his killers at motorcycle gang hangouts. It also discusses the possibility of French aviators crossing the Atlantic before Charles Lindbergh and a case…
- True Crime Rundown: Gerhardt & Arielle Konig
This episode of I Think Not! covers the trial of Gerhardt Konig, who is accused of attempting to murder his wife, Arielle Konig. The episode is sponsored by IQBAR.
- Episode 22 (Unsolved Mysteries)
This episode of I Think Not! covers three true crime cases: a man's account after being suspected of his mother's death, a woman who vanished following accusations of car fraud, and a murder related to a restaurant dispute. Information abo…
- True Crime Rundown: Kelsey Fitzsimmons
On I Think Not!, Ellyn and Joey review the Kelsey Fitzsimmons trial verdict. Fitzsimmons, accused by a police officer of attempted murder, was found not guilty of assault.
- Episode 21 (Unsolved Mysteries)
This episode of I Think Not! delves into two enduring mysteries: the persistent claims of a teen girl being seen after her supposed murder and the perilous, century-old quest for Arizona's Lost Dutchman's Mine.
- True Crime Rundown: Taylor Frankie Paul, The Duggars & More
This episode of I Think Not! provides a four-part true crime rundown, discussing the Kouri Richins trial verdict, Taylor Frankie Paul's involvement in The Bachelorette's cancellation, the Duggars' recent arrest, and Afroman's lawsuit.
- Episode 20 (Unsolved Mysteries)
This episode covers three mysteries: a fugitive cop in a swamp, a potential misidentification in the Billy the Kid case, and a strange vanishing act after a reunion.
- True Crime Rundown: Kouri Richins
On this episode of True Crime Rundown, Ellyn and Joey discuss the murder trial of Kouri Richins. She is accused of poisoning her husband, Eric Richins, with fentanyl in a drink in 2022.
- Episode 19 (Unsolved Mysteries)
Episode 19 discusses several unsolved mysteries: a bank vault emptied through an underground tunnel, a murder with three potential theories, and a young girl's near-death experience. Sponsors for this episode include IQ Bar, Blissy, and Re…
- True Crime Rundown: Britney Spears
This episode of I Think Not! features guest Daisy Eagan discussing Britney Spears. They cover Spears' timeline, conservatorship, recent arrest, and DUI.
- Episode 18 (Unsolved Mysteries)
This episode of I Think Not! covers three unsolved cases: the contract killing of auto-racing legend Mickey Thompson and his wife, a man who disappeared after opening bank accounts across the Midwest, and a convicted armed robber's three e…
- True Crime Rundown: Lindsay Clancy & The Epstein Files
On this episode of Rundown, Ellyn and Joey cover the latest on Lindsay Clancy, who appeared in court after being charged with murdering her three children. The discussion also revisits the Epstein files.
- Episode 17 (Unsolved Mysteries)
This episode discusses the 1962 escape from Alcatraz prison by three inmates who were never seen again, exploring the mystery surrounding their disappearance.
- True Crime Rundown: Les Wexner & Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor
On this episode of I Think Not!, Ellyn and Joey cover Les Wexner's deposition before the House Oversight Committee and Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor's arrest.
- Episode 16 (Unsolved Mysteries)
This episode of I Think Not! discusses several unsolved mysteries: the murder of an undercover vice cop, a businessman who disappeared leaving his car burning 400 miles away, a man searching for his separated sister, and a missing witness…
- True Crime Rundown: The Epstein Files (Part 2)
In Part 2 of The Epstein Files, Ellyn and Joey delve deeper into the case and also cover Pam Bondi’s hearing.
- Episode 15 (Unsolved Mysteries)
This episode of I Think Not! covers several unsolved mysteries, including a decades-old note from a murder witness, orphans searching for lost siblings, and a woman with apparent precognition about missing persons.
- True Crime Rundown: The Epstein Files
In this episode of I Think Not!, hosts Ellyn and Joey conduct a deep dive into the Epstein files, covering relevant emails and providing a summary of the essential information.
- Episode 14 (Unsolved Mysteries)
This episode of I Think Not! covers several unsolved mysteries: a teen's disappearance from a county fair, a sheriff's dying description of his attacker's car, a vanished prospector, and a young girl's abduction.
- True Crime Rundown: Luigi Mangione, Kristen Galvan, Cardi B & More
This episode covers updates on the federal case of Luigi Mangione, Brendan Banfield and Cardi B lawsuits, and the sentencing of Sean Grayson. It also includes an update on Kristen Galvan's case and a tribute to Catherine O'Hara.
- Episode 13 (Unsolved Mysteries)
This episode of I Think Not! covers three unsolved mysteries: the murder of a disc jockey after a high-speed duel, a man who disappeared from a Pennsylvania highway, and a case involving a 77-year-old man who defrauded victims.
- True Crime Rundown: Michael Proctor, Chad Franke & More
This episode of 'I Think Not!' covers several true crime stories. Hosts Ellyn and Joey discuss Chad Franke speaking out about his mother Ruby Franke, Brendan Banfield's upcoming testimony in a double murder case, and provide updates on Mic…
- Episode 12 (Unsolved Mysteries)
This episode covers three distinct cases: a Hungarian family's search for an American soldier who saved them, a man's disappearance after visiting an ATM in Los Angeles, and a husband's assertion of innocence regarding his wife's death.
- True Crime Rundown: Pam Smart, Spencer and Monique Tepe & Aaron Spencer
Special guest Mel Barrett discusses the Pam Smart and Aaron Spencer cases with Ellyn, who also updates on the Spencer and Monique Tepe case.
- Episode 11 (Unsolved Mysteries)
This episode of I Think Not! covers several unusual and unsolved cases, including a man found dead in two fires ten years apart, a woman who lost her memory after an attack, and a bank robber who got away with $1.3 million.
- True Crime Rundown: Renee Nicole Good, Spencer & Monique Tepe, Nick Reiner
This episode provides updates on three true crime cases: Nick Reiner's legal team, the fatal shooting of Renee Nicole Good by an ICE agent, and the deaths of Spencer and Monique Tepe in their Ohio home.
- Episode 10 (Unsolved Mysteries)
This episode of I Think Not! explores unsolved mysteries. Topics include a man's death following the discovery of his wife's infidelity, a family man's disappearance, and the phenomenon of missing time attributed to alien abductions.
- True Crime Rundown: Rob & Michele Reiner and Brian Walshe Sentencing
The first 2026 Rundown episode of I Think Not! covers the murders of Rob and Michele Reiner and the recent sentencing of Brian Walshe.
- Bonus from Patreon - Swagg Man (Smugshot)
This bonus episode of I Think Not! discusses Swagg Man, a French-Tunisian internet celebrity known for his rap career and entrepreneurial ventures, detailing his controversial activities and legal troubles.
- Bonus from Patreon - The Getaway (Smugshot)
This bonus episode of I Think Not!, previously exclusive to Patreon, details the bank robbery attempt of Anthony Cursio. His careful planning and getaway initially baffled police, but he failed to account for one critical element.
- Episode 9 (Unsolved Mysteries)
This episode of I Think Not! covers three mysterious cases: the unexplained death of a teenager, the discovery of a rock that brings good luck to two boys, and the fear of a killer targeting priests.
- True Crime Rundown: Karen Read and Brian Walshe Updates & More
This episode of True Crime Rundown features Joey discussing updates on the Karen Read case and the story of true crime TV producer Mary Carole McDonnell. Ellyn provides an update on Brian Walshe and covers the case of Michael Virgil.
- Episode 8 (Unsolved Mysteries)
This episode of I Think Not! covers three unsolved mysteries: a San Quentin prison escape, a husband searching for his missing wife while facing accusations, and a small-town figure who might be a conman.
- True Crime Rundown: Luigi Mangione & Brian Walshe
This episode of I Think Not! provides updates on two true crime cases. Joey covers the Luigi Mangione case, focusing on potential Miranda rights issues. Ellyn discusses the Brian Walshe case, highlighting the use of Google search history a…
- Episode 7 (Unsolved Mysteries)
This episode delves into three unsolved mysteries: new evidence suggesting the Son of Sam killer was involved in a satanic cult, an account of a waitress seeing a Revolutionary War soldier's ghost, and the puzzling disappearance of a wealt…
- True Crime Rundown: Kelsey Fitzsimmons & Minerliz "Minnie" Soriano
On True Crime Rundown, Ellyn and Joey cover the assault case of Kelsey Fitzsimmons, whose trial is set for February. They also share an update on the 1999 murder investigation of Minerliz "Minnie" Soriano.
- Bonus from Patreon: Unknown Number: The High School Catfish
As part of our dark week due to the holiday, we have a special surprise for you all! This is a bonus episode, previously exclusive to our Patreon and Apple Subscription pages and originally published on 9/25/25. Join now and get a ton of o…
- True Crime Rundown: Karen Read and Anna Kepner
This week's True Crime Rundown covers all of the most recent updates on Karen Read. Then, Ellyn and Joey also discuss the cause of death of Anna Kepner, who was found dead on a Carnival cruise ship earlier this month. Learn more about your…
- Episode 6 (Unsolved Mysteries)
A man is arrested for the Son of Sam killings in New York, but some believe he may not have acted alone. A deacon and his wife are the victims of a double murder in Georgia. A frugal bachelor leaves an unclaimed fortune. This Week’s Sponso…